Overrated

I choose Orson Welles for the simple reason that an orthodoxy has been established that amounts to a great ice sheet. Anyone asked the name of the greatest American film ever made —or even the best film produced anywhere—answers Citizen Kane . The pace has been set by the British film magazine Sight & Sound, which polls critics and filmmakers every 10 years. Starting in 1962, and at every 10-year bump up to 2002, Kane has come first. The movies are a young medium, but religious certainty has set in, and it is bad in nearly every way for critical thinking and the tender scrutiny of new films. While Welles had the ego to delight in his own glory, he also possessed a mind that would have argued fiercely against taking such a thing for granted. Not the least problem with the attitude is that no one really feels the need to watch Citizen Kane any more. It has become like one of those pieces of the classical musical repertoire, such a known quantity that people don’t want to hear it again or bother to listen when it is played.

The best demonstration of this is the widespread assertion that Citizen Kane is a very clever, cold, intellectual, tricksy film that pioneered all manner of new techniques. There’s truth in that assertion. But it is much more urgent to feel the film. Citizen Kane is an intensely emotional picture in which a great egotist measures achievement against utility. In that sense it is Welles at 25 realizing that he had almost certainly done his best work and beginning to sense the desperation of wondering what else he could do.

Equally, just because it was so far ahead of its time and a period piece, it is not always easy to see that Citizen Kane is a prediction about personality in politics and self-absorption in power in the years yet to come.

So the acceptance of Kane deters its proper appreciation. The film is both overrated and ignored. There should be a moratorium on it. It should become impossible to see, as it was in 1952, when it did not figure in the Sight & Sound poll.

Underrated

Ladies and gentlemen, clearly the most criminally underrated director in world film is … Orson Welles. For all the reasons indicated above, the public has taken up an increasingly rigid attitude that whereas Citizen Kane is great, and perhaps the greatest, Welles went into a helpless decline thereafter and could never match his own heights. Further, he was temperamentally so arrogant and difficult that he could never again find the ideal working conditions he had had on Citizen Kane at RKO. Therefore, it’s all downhill after 1941.

What nonsense. If