Authors:
Historic Era: Era 2: Colonization and Settlement (1585-1763)
Historic Theme:
Subject:
Fall 2023 | Volume 68, Issue 7
Authors:
Historic Era: Era 2: Colonization and Settlement (1585-1763)
Historic Theme:
Subject:
Fall 2023 | Volume 68, Issue 7
Editor’s Note: Jonathan Cohen is a poet, translator, and scholar with expertise in inter-American literature. Portions of this essay originally appeared in The American Voice.
America, we learn as schoolchildren, was named in honor of Amerigo Vespucci for his discovery of the mainland of the New World. We tend not to question this lesson about the naming of America. By the time we are adults, it lingers vaguely in most of us, along with images of wave-tossed caravels and forests peopled with naked cannibals. Not surprisingly, the notion that America was named for Vespucci has long been universally accepted, so much so that a lineal descendant, America Vespucci, went to New Orleans in 1839 and asked for a land grant "in recognition of her name and parentage." Since the late 19th century, however, conflicting ideas about the truth of the derivation have been set forth, and have had profound cultural and political implications. To question the origin of America's name is to question the truth of not only our history lessons, but our very identity as Americans.
Traditional history lessons about the discovery of America also raise questions about the meaning of discovery itself. It is now universally recognized that neither Vespucci nor Columbus "discovered" America. They were of course preceded by the pre-historic Asian forebears of Native Americans, who migrated across some ice-bridge in the Bering Straits or over the stepping stones of the Aleutian Islands. A black African discovery of America, it has been argued, took place around 3000 years ago, and influenced the development of Mayan, Aztec, and Inca civilizations.
The records of Scandinavian expeditions to America are found in sagas — their historic cores encrusted with additions made by every storyteller who had ever repeated them. The Icelandic Saga of Eric the Red, the settler of Greenland, which tells how Eric's son Leif came to Vinland, was first written down in the second half of the 13th century, 250 years after Leif found a western land full of "wheatfields and vines"; from this history emerged a fanciful theory in 1930 that the origin of "America" is Scandinavian: Amt meaning "district," and Eric was added to that to form Amteric, or the Land of (Leif) Eric.
Other Norsemen went out to the land that Leif had discovered; in fact, contemporary advocates of the Norse connection claim that, from around the beginning of the 11th century, North Atlantic sailors called this place Ommerike (oh-MEH-ric-eh), an Old Norse word meaning "farthest outland." (This theory is currently being promoted