“Let’s Go,” Said Mrs. Graham. “Let’s Publish” (Summer 2021 | Volume: 65, Issue: 5)

“Let’s Go,” Said Mrs. Graham. “Let’s Publish”

AH article image

Authors: Leonard Downie

Historic Era: Era 10: Contemporary United States (1968 to the present)

Historic Theme:

Subject:

Summer 2021 | Volume 65, Issue 5

new York times
The cover of The New York Times on the day the Pentagon Papers were published. Nixon Library

Editor’s Note: Leonard Downie Jr. was a reporter and editor for 44 years at the Washington Post and now teaches journalism at the Cronkite School. During his 17 years as executive editor, the Post won 25 Pulitzer prizes. Mr. Downie has adapted the following essay from his recent book, All About the Story: News, Power, Politics and The Washington Post.

In June 1971, I was working as a city editor at the Washington Post when publication of the Pentagon Papers by the New York Times and our paper created a nationwide furor.

Although I wasn’t directly involved, I had a ringside seat as the publication of the papers shook all branches of the government, and there was a nationwide debate on what constituted “classified” material and how much should be made public.

I had a ringside seat as the publication of the papers shook all branches of the government.

What became known as the Pentagon Papers was a secret, 7000-page study of U.S. involvement in Vietnam commissioned by President Lyndon B. Johnson’s secretary of defense, Robert McNamara, and carried out by the Defense Department. It documented a history of missteps and lies by the Truman, Eisenhower, Kennedy, and Johnson administrations as they escalated American involvement in what became the costly, lost-cause Vietnam War.

Leonard Downie speaking at the National Press Club in 2007. (Photo: Terissa Schor/Flickr Creative Commons)
Leonard Downie speaking at the National Press Club in 2007. Terissa Schor/Flickr Creative Commons

Military analyst Daniel Ellsberg, who had worked on the classified study and evolved into an opponent of the war, spirited a copy out of his office safe at the Rand Corporation in Los Angeles and painstakingly photocopied it page by page over many weeks. After he failed to find interest in it among several Washington officials and politicians, the report made its way to the New York Times.

The first anyone else knew about this was when the Times published its initial story on June 13, 1971. President Richard Nixon, who was already worried about mounting American opposition to the war, asked the Justice Department to seek a court order stopping the Times from publishing top-secret information that, his administration argued, could cause irreparable harm to the United States. An injunction was granted stopping publication, for the first time in American history, after three days of Times stories.

Katharine Graham, publisher of The Washington Post, at a meeting of the Dutch Newspaper Press in May 1975. (Wikimedia Commons)
Katharine Graham, publisher of The Washington Post, at a meeting of the Dutch Newspaper Press in May 1975. Wikimedia Commons

Ellsberg then gave 4,000 pages of the study to Post national editor Ben Bagdikian, who had also once worked at Rand. As depicted in the 2018