Dr. Lauderdale Goes to War (December 1993 | Volume: 44, Issue: 8)

Dr. Lauderdale Goes to War

AH article image

Authors: Geoffrey C. Ward

Historic Era: Era 5: Civil War and Reconstruction (1850-1877)

Historic Theme:

Subject:

December 1993 | Volume 44, Issue 8

Sometimes, if you wait long enough, things just work out. More than 20 years ago, when I was living in Boston and editing a long-vanished magazine called Audience, I was lunching with Gerald Lauderdale, the adman who handled our direct-mail solicitations, and mentioned to him idly that I was thinking someday of writing a book about my great-grandfather. Gerry listened politely until I said that I’d recently been to upstate New York to have a look at the old family home in Geneseo. “Geneseo!” he said. “That’s where my family comes from. We have books of my grandfather’s letters. He was a doctor in the Civil War. Would you like to see them?

I said I would. A Dr. Walter E. Lauderdale had been my family’s doctor in those years, I knew, and the Lauderdales had been members of the Old School Presbyterian congregation over which my great-great-grandfather, the father of my subject, presided. The letter writer must have been one of Dr. Lauderdale’s sons.

The letters were eventually delivered to my office. The most I’d hoped for was two or three slim little volumes in which, if I were lucky, my ancestors’ physical frailties might now and again be mentioned. What I got were several big cartons crammed with oversized volumes containing thousands of letters home—detailing, almost day by day, a medical and military career that stretched from the late 1850s well into this century—all carefully arranged chronologically, written in a big, clear hand, and supplemented with sketches, photographs, souvenirs.

It seemed to me that these documents needed a safer harbor than they’d had, and with Gerry Lauderdale’s permission, I described them in a letter to Archibald Hanna, then the curator of the Western American Collection at Yale’s Beinecke Library. He agreed to give them a home.

 

I was pleased, but also a little guilty. I knew that someone should edit the Lauderdale papers into a book—or series of books—and as the years went by and no volume ever appeared, I began to feel that I had been derelict, somehow, in not trying to produce one myself.

I needn’t have worried. This summer, to my surprise and pleasure, appeared The Wounded River: The Civil War Letters of John Vance Lauderdale, M.D., ably edited by Peter Josyph.

John Lauderdale was a conventional young man, not especially brave or notably sensitive and more prim than most (he did not marry until late in life and seems to have been generally tongue-tied and disapproving around women). And he was prone to pious judgments all his life, many of which, I’m sorry to say, were likely inspired by the grim sermons to which he was subjected twice each Sunday by my ancestor: He went to hear Louis Agassiz speak one Sunday, for example, but was unable to enjoy it because he questioned “very much the propriety of such a [scientific] lecture on the sabbath.”

But what matters is