William Kidd: Good Guy, Bad Guy (July/August 1988 | Volume: 39, Issue: 5)

William Kidd: Good Guy, Bad Guy

AH article image

Authors:

Historic Era:

Historic Theme:

Subject:

July/August 1988 | Volume 39, Issue 5

Most overrated:

Capt. William Kidd (c. 1645-1701) of New York City. His reputation as our outstanding pirate is a gross exaggeration, although he did hang for it. Had he been half the pirate his punishment suggested, Kidd would have left some valuable treasure buried somewhere.

 

Most underrated:

My nomination goes to the same William Kidd, the sea captain. As a householder, a family man, and a leading citizen, he was devoted to civic causes. Trinity Church could not have been built without Kidd’s generous contributions.