Story

Where the Declaration Was “Signed in Blood”

AH article image

Authors: Chase Brush

Historic Era: Era 3: Revolution and the New Nation (1754-1820s)

Historic Theme:

Subject:

November/December 2026 | Volume 71, Issue 5

The Battle of Brooklyn has been called a "fiasco" that might have ended America's campaign for independence had it not been for the heroism of a handful of courageous men. Today, a historic stone farmhouse celebrates their defeat. 

Chase Brush

November/December 2026 | Volume 71, Issue 5

osh
The flag of Maryland hangs outside the Old Stone House in honor of the Maryland 400's sacrifice. Chase Brush

At first glance, Washington Park, a roughly one-square-block green space in the Park Slope neighborhood of South Brooklyn, does not seem so different from many of the hundreds of other parks strewn throughout New York City's most populous borough. Surrounded by Gilded Age brownstones and steel highrises, the park serves as a gathering place for the wider community, attracting visitors of all ages and backgrounds. On a typical summer afternoon, children can be found frolicking across the playground, while teenagers on scooters and skateboards zip along concrete ramps in the skatepark nearby. There is a turf field for soccer and baseball games, a dog run, and a picnic area where neighbors gather to eat and converse. The park’s visitors, naturally, reflect the diversity of the city itself: black, white, Latino, Asian, a heaping helping of the melting pot that is New York.

Two and a half centuries ago, it was at this former Dutch farmstead where four hundred Maryland regulars made their dramatic stand against the British, just a month and a half after the signing of the Declaration of Independence.

And yet amid this portrait of contemporary urban life, it's easy to overlook one of the park's defining—and most historic—features. Standing between the turf field and a community garden is an old stone house, unassuming in size yet distinct in design from the nearby buildings, with rough stone walls, weathered wooden shutters, and a sloping tin roof. Despite its seemingly historic nature, many who frequent the park mistake the structure for a utility building, or know only that it houses the nearest public bathrooms. Upon closer scrutiny, the most out-of-place detail may be the flag that often hangs from the second-story window—a flag flying the colors not of Brooklyn or New York but of Maryland, a state some 200 miles away. 

This is, literally, The Old Stone House, though the name hardly begins to describe the true age of the site nor its importance in the long history of Brooklyn, New York City, or even in the founding history of the country. Two and a half centuries ago, it was at this former Dutch farmstead where a group of Maryland regulars made their dramatic last stand against an overwhelming British opponent, just a month and a half after the U.S. became an independent nation with the signing of the Declaration of Independence. Many of these soldiers perished. But their sacrifice bought the rest of the army, including its leader, General George Washington, just enough time to retreat to Manhattan and escape British capture. In that sense, the defeat was a kind of victory for the young country, summed up in a quote from the local historian and preservationist Charles Higgins: “The Declaration was signed in ink in Philadelphia, but it was sealed in blood in Brooklyn.”

All this can sound like ancient history to a 21st-century New Yorker, and understandably few people who visit the park today realize that they are standing on what was once a blood-soaked battlefield, not to mention a place where, had things gone differently in that last week of August in 1776, they might not be standing at all. A longtime Brooklyn resident, I hadn't known it either until I stumbled upon the house myself one summer afternoon and was surprised to find a small museum inside, featuring displays on the history of early Brooklyn and its role in the American Revolution. The building itself, now listed on the National Register of Historic Places, is a reconstruction of the original Vechte-Cortelyou house, a Dutch farmstead built near the property in the late 1600s. Though usually pretty inconspicuous, anyone within earshot of the house might also have learned about it this August, when the air was filled with the sounds of war as hundreds of redcoats and colonials descended on the park to reenact the battle on its 250th anniversary. 

As visitors to the Old Stone House are quick to learn, Manhattan wasn’t the only place, and arguably not even the most important place, within the modern-day boundaries of New York where the Revolution played out.

“People initially come for the events and the gardens, but they also absorb and become engaged with the history,” says Kim Maier, the executive director of the Old Stone House & Washington Park, a historic conservancy organization that is part of the city’s Historic House Trust. “And the 250th anniversary has led to even more awareness of and appreciation for that history.”

In a city as fast-moving and forward-looking as New York, perhaps this lack of immediate interest in the Revolution is unsurprising. New Yorkers are not exactly the types to be overly precious about their history; this is, after all, the City of Dreams, a place of new beginnings and fresh starts where for hundreds of years immigrants and idealists have traveled to escape the past, not relive it. When it comes to the Revolution, that may explain why the city’s urban landscape seems devoid of historical landmarks and monuments—at least compared with other founding-era cities such as Philadelphia or Boston, where it’s hard to walk down the sidewalk without tripping over a memorial plaque to some long-gone event or figure. At the same time, if there is any borough associated with the war in New York, it is probably Manhattan, once called the “cockpit of the Revolution” alongside neighboring New Jersey for its concentration of 18th-century rebel activity. Fraunces Tavern, where Washington gave his farewell address in 1785; Federal Hall, where colonists protested the Stamp Act Congress in 1765;