Story

The Booth Obsession

AH article image

Authors: Gene Smith

Historic Era: Era 5: Civil War and Reconstruction (1850-1877)

Historic Theme:

Subject:

September 1992 | Volume 43, Issue 5

The first non-children’s book I ever read was Philip Van Doren Stern’s novel The Man Who Killed Lincoln. How it fell into my hands, I cannot say. I retain a clear memory of going to my mother to inquire about what appeared on page 16: “A big buck Negro, whose black skin glistened with sweat, held in his arms a young mulatto girl who was hysterical with desire.” Very baffling. What could it mean?

My mother studied the passage. There was a long silence. My mother wore rimless spectacles. It would be unthinkable for her to depart our New York City apartment in anything but a dress or skirt and high heels. She finally made a reply to my request for an explanation: “ I…don’t…know .”

Apparently, this is a familiar type of rite for many children. The editor of this magazine tells me that he once went to an uncle to ask the meaning of a word in a grown-up’s book that he had happened across. The word was "rapist." The uncle, as with my mother, studied the matter for a time and then offered the explanation that this term defines: “a guy who bothers women.”

 
 
All who knew him wondered why he did it, and some still said, decades later, that it was impossible to believe.

I finished the book. Some years later, my family drove south. I prevailed upon my parents to go down Route 301 in Virginia so that I could see the spot where the man who killed Lincoln died. We pulled off the road at the historical marker, and I rooted about for remnants of the barn set on fire in April of 1865 by the Yankee cavalry or of the house where, shot through the neck, the assassin breathed his last. I found nothing. When we got home, I wrote Philip Van Doren Stern. He replied with a letter dated June 20, 1949, addressing me as “Dear Mr. Smith,” a usage to which I was not much accustomed. I still have the book, and the letter. In the early 1970s, when I was inducted into the Society of American Historians, the first of my fellow members who I sought out was Philip Van Doren Stern. I reminded him of our correspondence of a quarter-century earlier. He said he thought he remembered. A kid wrote asking about the exact location of where Lincoln’s assassin died—wasn’t that it?

Yes. That was it. And now, at an age that, only with great imprecision, can be described as far beyond that of a kid, I have returned to the matter that captured me so very long ago. My book on Junius Brutus Booth, the actor-father, and Edwin and John, the actor sons, will be published this month. Today, one son, Edwin, stands in bronze in New York